Is Liverpool boss Jurgen Klopp’s Man Utd penalty claim correct?

Jurgen Klopp in contrast Liverpool’s penalty document to Manchester United‘s – however does he have some extent?

The champions slipped to a second league defeat of the season at Southampton on Monday, with Klopp annoyed his aspect weren’t profitable with two second-half penalty appeals.

Manchester United

Sunday seventeenth January 4:00pm

Kick off 4:30pm

Kyle Walker-Peters’ problem on Sadio Mane and Jack Stephens’ handball whereas blocking Georginio Wijnaldum’s shot each went unpunished by referee Andre Marriner, prompting Klopp to spotlight the disparity between the variety of penalties awarded to Liverpool in comparison with rivals Manchester United.

“I hear now that Manchester United had more penalties in two years than I had in five-and-a-half-years,” Klopp mentioned. “I’ve no idea if that’s my fault, or how that can happen.”


Jamie Carragher analyses whether or not Liverpool ought to have had a penalty after Sadio Mane was introduced down within the field towards Southampton

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer later laughed off Klopp’s comparability of the membership’s penalty information.

The United boss mentioned he wouldn’t spend his time counting as his aspect put together to host Manchester City within the Carabao Cup semi-final on Wednesday night, stay on Sky Sports – however steered the purpose may have been made to affect referees

“That’s a fact? Probably,” mentioned Solskjaer. “That’s most likely going to be my reply, that is a reality that we have got greater than them. I do not rely what number of penalties they’ve had, so in the event that they wish to spend time on worrying about once we get fouled within the field… I do not spend time on that.

Also See:

  • So’ton 1-0 Liverpool – Match report
  • Klopp compares penalty information
  • Carra on Liverpool creativity points
  • Get Sky Sports

“I can’t talk on behalf of other managers, why they say things like this,” he added, earlier than making reference to a penalty shout which was missed of their FA Cup semi-final defeat to Chelsea final season.

“I felt it worked last year in the semi in the FA Cup, because Frank [Lampard] spoke about it and we had a nailed-on penalty that we should have had, that we didn’t get.

“So possibly it is a approach of influencing the referees. I do not know. But I do not fear about that. When they foul our gamers it is a penalty when it is contained in the field.”


Ole Gunnar Solskjaer has his say on Jurgen Klopp’s claim that there is a disparity between the variety of penalties awarded to Liverpool in comparison with Manchester United.

  • Jurgen Klopp compares Liverpool penalty document to Man Utd
  • Ole Gunnar Solskjaer: Klopp’s pen level could also be to affect refs
  • Southampton 1-0 Liverpool – Match report and highlights
  • Analysis: Jamie Carragher on Liverpool’s creativity points
  • Ref Watch: Liverpool penalty selections appropriate

Have Man Utd had extra penalties than Liverpool?

Since Jurgen Klopp took the reins at Anfield in early October 2015, Manchester United have been awarded 41 penalties, 11 greater than Liverpool; round an additional two per season on common.

In the early years of the Klopp dynasty, nonetheless, when Jose Mourinho was in cost at Old Trafford, the finger was pointed to the spot much more in Liverpool’s favour than for his or her previous rivals.

In 2016/17, Liverpool have been awarded eight to United’s 4. Liverpool did rating 24 extra objectives throughout the course of the season which may go some solution to explaining that – however that they had solely 100 touches extra within the opposition penalty space.

The following season, when Mourinho’s United completed runners-up within the Premier League, they scored solely 68 objectives to Liverpool’s 84, and had 206 fewer touches within the opposition field than Liverpool, however either side have been awarded three spot kicks over the course of the marketing campaign.

Liverpool did, although, rating six extra objectives than within the earlier season, suggesting Klopp’s aspect had develop into extra scientific fairly than merely unfortunate with referees’ selections.

Ole arrival marks swing in Man Utd’s favour

Things started to swing away from Liverpool’s favour halfway into the next season, although.

As Mourinho departed Old Trafford and Solskjaer took his place, quick breaks and counter-attacking soccer grew to become the order of the day, and shortly United’s numbers started to rise.

Jesse Lingard scored from the spot in Solskjaer’s first Premier League victory in his first sport in command of Manchester United towards Cardiff in December 2018.

Since then, no membership has taken extra (27) or scored extra (21) penalties than United. By distinction, throughout the identical interval, Liverpool have taken simply 17 Premier League penalties.

So, is Klopp proper?

Klopp has some extent concerning the disparity in numbers of free photographs at aim awarded to United in comparison with Liverpool, particularly within the final couple of years, though his numbers on the precise comparability have been barely out.

Klopp’s intention might have been to attract consideration to among the extra doubtful spot kicks awarded to Solskjaer’s aspect which have rightly been known as into query – just like the one Bruno Fernandes gained and transformed towards Aston Villa throughout Project Restart, regardless of the Portuguese showing to provoke contact with Ezri Konsa.

But, as Klopp admitted after the defeat at St. Mary’s, so too have Liverpool’s gamers been criticised for taking place simply, with the supervisor referencing Mane’s last-minute penalty win towards Leicester in the identical season.

So whereas the information can say one factor, it could be a stretch too far to claim United have had a straightforward journey with referees in comparison with Liverpool during the last 5 years – however thoughts video games have not at all times adopted logic to the letter.

Win £250,000 without spending a dime with Super 6!

Do not miss your likelihood to land the £250,000 in Saturday's Super 6 spherical. Play without spending a dime, entries by 3:00pm.


Related posts